Compare local authorities · Yorkshire and The Humber and Scotland
Sheffield and Dundee City
Sheffield is higher than Dundee City on 6 of 22 measures per person in the age group, 4 of 22 per resident and 22 of 22 in total.
On 18 of 22 measures, which area is higher depends on whether you count per person or in total. Choose a way of counting below to see each one.
Per person in the age group
Sheffield is higher on 6 of 22 measures, and Dundee City on 16. Each row has its own scale from zero. Money is in 2026-27 prices2026-27 prices, using CPI inflationcash terms, not adjusted for inflation.1-11
Sheffield Dundee City
All benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£4,470£4,489£4,240Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£5,251£5,273£4,981
Pensioner benefitsper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£12,806£12,860£12,147Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£13,112£13,168£12,437
Working-age benefitsper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£2,232£2,241£2,117Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£2,582£2,593£2,449
State Pensionper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£11,374£11,422£10,788Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£11,544£11,593£10,950
Pension Creditper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£601£604£570Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£634£637£601
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£795£798£754Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£899£903£853
Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£36£36£34Sheffield is higherDepends on how you count£35£35£33
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£543£545£515Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£766£769£727
Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£161£162£153Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£196£197£186
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£161£161£152Sheffield is higher£139£140£132
Universal Creditper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£1,670£1,677£1,584Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£1,901£1,909£1,803
Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25
£259£260£245Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£322£324£306
Employment and Support Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£378£380£359Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£524£526£497
Jobseeker's Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£10£10£9.49Sheffield is higher£7.28£7.32£6.91
Income Supportper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£13£13£12Sheffield is higher£11£11£10
Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£5.49£5.52£5.21Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£6.37£6.39£6.04
State Pensionper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026
1,006.3Sheffield is higherDepends on how you count1,002.7
Pension Creditper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026
135.8Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count155.5
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026
163.9Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count204.4
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026
79.9Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count121.2
Universal Creditper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, May 2026
213.2Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count238.1
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, March 2026
36.2Sheffield is higher32.5
Show the numbers
| Measure | Sheffield | Dundee City | Higher |
|---|---|---|---|
| All benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £4,470£4,489£4,240 | £5,251£5,273£4,981Estimated | Dundee City |
| Pensioner benefitsper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £12,806£12,860£12,147 | £13,112£13,168£12,437Estimated | Dundee City |
| Working-age benefitsper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £2,232£2,241£2,117 | £2,582£2,593£2,449Estimated | Dundee City |
| State Pensionper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £11,374£11,422£10,788 | £11,544£11,593£10,950 | Dundee City |
| Pension Creditper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £601£604£570 | £634£637£601 | Dundee City |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £795£798£754 | £899£903£853Estimated | Dundee City |
| Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £36£36£34 | £35£35£33Estimated | Sheffield |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £543£545£515 | £766£769£727Estimated | Dundee City |
| Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £161£162£153 | £196£197£186Estimated | Dundee City |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £161£161£152 | £139£140£132Estimated | Sheffield |
| Universal Creditper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £1,670£1,677£1,584 | £1,901£1,909£1,803 | Dundee City |
| Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25 | £259£260£245 | £322£324£306 | Dundee City |
| Employment and Support Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £378£380£359 | £524£526£497 | Dundee City |
| Jobseeker's Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £10£10£9.49 | £7.28£7.32£6.91 | Sheffield |
| Income Supportper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £13£13£12 | £11£11£10 | Sheffield |
| Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £5.49£5.52£5.21 | £6.37£6.39£6.04Estimated | Dundee City |
| State Pensionper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026 | 1,006.3 | 1,002.7 | Sheffield |
| Pension Creditper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026 | 135.8 | 155.5 | Dundee City |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026 | 163.9 | 204.4 | Dundee City |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026 | 79.9 | 121.2 | Dundee City |
| Universal Creditper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, May 2026 | 213.2 | 238.1 | Dundee City |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, March 2026 | 36.2 | 32.5Estimated | Sheffield |
Per resident
Sheffield is higher on 4 of 22 measures, and Dundee City on 18. Each row has its own scale from zero. Money is in 2026-27 prices2026-27 prices, using CPI inflationcash terms, not adjusted for inflation.1-11
Sheffield Dundee City
All benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£4,470£4,489£4,240Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£5,251£5,273£4,981
Pensioner benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£2,036£2,045£1,931Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£2,266£2,275£2,149
Working-age benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£1,465£1,472£1,390Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£1,694£1,702£1,607
State Pensionper resident, 2024-25
£1,808£1,816£1,715Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£1,995£2,003£1,892
Pension Creditper resident, 2024-25
£96£96£91Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£110£110£104
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£126£127£120Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£155£156£147
Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£5.66£5.69£5.37Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£5.99£6.01£5.68
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£543£545£515Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£766£769£727
Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£161£162£153Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£196£197£186
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£105£106£100Sheffield is higher£91£92£87
Universal Creditper resident, 2024-25
£1,097£1,101£1,040Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£1,247£1,253£1,183
Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25
£259£260£245Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£322£324£306
Employment and Support Allowanceper resident, 2024-25
£248£249£236Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£344£345£326
Jobseeker's Allowanceper resident, 2024-25
£6.57£6.60£6.23Sheffield is higher£4.78£4.80£4.53
Income Supportper resident, 2024-25
£8.46£8.49£8.02Sheffield is higher£7.07£7.10£6.71
Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£5.49£5.52£5.21Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count£6.37£6.39£6.04
State Pensionper 1,000 residents, March 2026
160.0Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count173.3
Pension Creditper 1,000 residents, March 2026
21.6Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count26.9
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026
26.1Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count35.3
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026
79.9Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count121.2
Universal Creditper 1,000 residents, May 2026
140.0Dundee City is higherDepends on how you count156.3
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026
23.7Sheffield is higher21.3
Show the numbers
| Measure | Sheffield | Dundee City | Higher |
|---|---|---|---|
| All benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £4,470£4,489£4,240 | £5,251£5,273£4,981Estimated | Dundee City |
| Pensioner benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £2,036£2,045£1,931 | £2,266£2,275£2,149Estimated | Dundee City |
| Working-age benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £1,465£1,472£1,390 | £1,694£1,702£1,607Estimated | Dundee City |
| State Pensionper resident, 2024-25 | £1,808£1,816£1,715 | £1,995£2,003£1,892 | Dundee City |
| Pension Creditper resident, 2024-25 | £96£96£91 | £110£110£104 | Dundee City |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £126£127£120 | £155£156£147Estimated | Dundee City |
| Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £5.66£5.69£5.37 | £5.99£6.01£5.68Estimated | Dundee City |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £543£545£515 | £766£769£727Estimated | Dundee City |
| Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £161£162£153 | £196£197£186Estimated | Dundee City |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £105£106£100 | £91£92£87Estimated | Sheffield |
| Universal Creditper resident, 2024-25 | £1,097£1,101£1,040 | £1,247£1,253£1,183 | Dundee City |
| Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25 | £259£260£245 | £322£324£306 | Dundee City |
| Employment and Support Allowanceper resident, 2024-25 | £248£249£236 | £344£345£326 | Dundee City |
| Jobseeker's Allowanceper resident, 2024-25 | £6.57£6.60£6.23 | £4.78£4.80£4.53 | Sheffield |
| Income Supportper resident, 2024-25 | £8.46£8.49£8.02 | £7.07£7.10£6.71 | Sheffield |
| Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £5.49£5.52£5.21 | £6.37£6.39£6.04Estimated | Dundee City |
| State Pensionper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 160.0 | 173.3 | Dundee City |
| Pension Creditper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 21.6 | 26.9 | Dundee City |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 26.1 | 35.3 | Dundee City |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026 | 79.9 | 121.2 | Dundee City |
| Universal Creditper 1,000 residents, May 2026 | 140.0 | 156.3 | Dundee City |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 23.7 | 21.3Estimated | Sheffield |
Total
Sheffield is higher on 22 of 22 measures, and Dundee City on 0. Each row has its own scale from zero. Money is in 2026-27 prices2026-27 prices, using CPI inflationcash terms, not adjusted for inflation.1-11
Sheffield Dundee City
All benefitstotal, 2024-25
£2.6bn£2.6bn£2.5bnSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£784.1m£787.5m£743.8m
Pensioner benefitstotal, 2024-25
£1.2bn£1.2bn£1.1bnSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£338.3m£339.8m£320.9m
Working-age benefitstotal, 2024-25
£850.3m£853.9m£806.5mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£253.0m£254.1m£240.0m
State Pensiontotal, 2024-25
£1.0bn£1.1bn£995.3mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£297.9m£299.1m£282.5m
Pension Credittotal, 2024-25
£55.5m£55.7m£52.6mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£16.4m£16.4m£15.5m
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£73.4m£73.7m£69.6mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£23.2m£23.3m£22.0m
Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£3.3m£3.3m£3.1mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£0.89m£0.90m£0.85m
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£315.2m£316.5m£298.9mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£114.4m£114.9m£108.5m
Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£93.5m£93.9m£88.6mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£29.3m£29.4m£27.8m
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£61.2m£61.5m£58.0mSheffield is higher£13.6m£13.7m£12.9m
Universal Credittotal, 2024-25
£636.3m£639.0m£603.5mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£186.3m£187.1m£176.7m
Housing Benefittotal, 2024-25
£150.0m£150.7m£142.3mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£48.2m£48.4m£45.7m
Employment and Support Allowancetotal, 2024-25
£144.1m£144.7m£136.7mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£51.3m£51.5m£48.7m
Jobseeker's Allowancetotal, 2024-25
£3.8m£3.8m£3.6mSheffield is higher£0.71m£0.72m£0.68m
Income Supporttotal, 2024-25
£4.9m£4.9m£4.7mSheffield is higher£1.1m£1.1m£1.0m
Other benefitstotal, 2024-25
£3.2m£3.2m£3.0mSheffield is higherDepends on how you count£0.95m£0.96m£0.90m
State Pensiontotal, March 2026
92,834Sheffield is higherDepends on how you count25,872
Pension Credittotal, March 2026
12,528Sheffield is higherDepends on how you count4,011
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, March 2026
15,120Sheffield is higherDepends on how you count5,275
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, July 2026
46,363Sheffield is higherDepends on how you count18,095
Universal Credittotal, May 2026
81,231Sheffield is higherDepends on how you count23,337
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, March 2026
13,773Sheffield is higher3,180
Show the numbers
| Measure | Sheffield | Dundee City | Higher |
|---|---|---|---|
| All benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £2.6bn£2.6bn£2.5bn | £784.1m£787.5m£743.8mEstimated | Sheffield |
| Pensioner benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £1.2bn£1.2bn£1.1bn | £338.3m£339.8m£320.9mEstimated | Sheffield |
| Working-age benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £850.3m£853.9m£806.5m | £253.0m£254.1m£240.0mEstimated | Sheffield |
| State Pensiontotal, 2024-25 | £1.0bn£1.1bn£995.3m | £297.9m£299.1m£282.5m | Sheffield |
| Pension Credittotal, 2024-25 | £55.5m£55.7m£52.6m | £16.4m£16.4m£15.5m | Sheffield |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £73.4m£73.7m£69.6m | £23.2m£23.3m£22.0mEstimated | Sheffield |
| Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £3.3m£3.3m£3.1m | £0.89m£0.90m£0.85mEstimated | Sheffield |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £315.2m£316.5m£298.9m | £114.4m£114.9m£108.5mEstimated | Sheffield |
| Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £93.5m£93.9m£88.6m | £29.3m£29.4m£27.8mEstimated | Sheffield |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £61.2m£61.5m£58.0m | £13.6m£13.7m£12.9mEstimated | Sheffield |
| Universal Credittotal, 2024-25 | £636.3m£639.0m£603.5m | £186.3m£187.1m£176.7m | Sheffield |
| Housing Benefittotal, 2024-25 | £150.0m£150.7m£142.3m | £48.2m£48.4m£45.7m | Sheffield |
| Employment and Support Allowancetotal, 2024-25 | £144.1m£144.7m£136.7m | £51.3m£51.5m£48.7m | Sheffield |
| Jobseeker's Allowancetotal, 2024-25 | £3.8m£3.8m£3.6m | £0.71m£0.72m£0.68m | Sheffield |
| Income Supporttotal, 2024-25 | £4.9m£4.9m£4.7m | £1.1m£1.1m£1.0m | Sheffield |
| Other benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £3.2m£3.2m£3.0m | £0.95m£0.96m£0.90mEstimated | Sheffield |
| State Pensiontotal, March 2026 | 92,834 | 25,872 | Sheffield |
| Pension Credittotal, March 2026 | 12,528 | 4,011 | Sheffield |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, March 2026 | 15,120 | 5,275 | Sheffield |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, July 2026 | 46,363 | 18,095 | Sheffield |
| Universal Credittotal, May 2026 | 81,231 | 23,337 | Sheffield |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, March 2026 | 13,773 | 3,180Estimated | Sheffield |
Sources
Each area's page lists the limits of its figures and where each one comes from.
- 1Department for Work and Pensions. Benefit expenditure by local authority, 2024-25. Published 15 December 2025. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 2Department for Work and Pensions. Benefit expenditure by parliamentary constituency, 2024-25. Published 15 December 2025. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 3Department for Work and Pensions. Stat-Xplore benefit caseloads and awards. Published 6 October 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 4Social Security Scotland. Adult Disability Payment statistics to 31 July 2026. Published 14 September 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 5Social Security Scotland. Child Disability Payment statistics to 30 June 2026. Published 17 August 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 6Social Security Scotland. Pension Age Disability Payment statistics to 31 July 2026. Published 14 September 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 7Social Security Scotland. Carer Support Payment statistics to 30 June 2026. Published 10 August 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 8Social Security Scotland. Winter heating benefits statistics for winter 2025/26. Published 18 May 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 9Office for National Statistics. Population estimates by local authority (Nomis NM_2002_1). Published 5 October 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 10Office for National Statistics. Population estimates by 2024 parliamentary constituency (Nomis NM_2014_1). Published 5 October 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 11National Records of Scotland. Population estimates for other geographies, mid-2011 to mid-2024. Published 31 August 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.