Compare constituencies · West Midlands and North East
Birmingham Erdington and Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
Birmingham Erdington is higher than Middlesbrough and Thornaby East on 12 of 22 measures per person in the age group, 10 of 22 per resident and 16 of 22 in total.
On 6 of 22 measures, which area is higher depends on whether you count per person or in total. Choose a way of counting below to see each one.
Per person in the age group
Birmingham Erdington is higher on 12 of 22 measures, and Middlesbrough and Thornaby East on 10. Each row has its own scale from zero. Money is in 2026-27 prices2026-27 prices, using CPI inflationcash terms, not adjusted for inflation.1-11
Birmingham Erdington Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
All benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£5,611£5,635£5,322Birmingham Erdington is higher£5,148£5,170£4,883
Pensioner benefitsper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£13,257£13,313£12,574Birmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count£13,209£13,266£12,530
Working-age benefitsper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£3,587£3,602£3,402Birmingham Erdington is higher£3,385£3,399£3,210
State Pensionper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£11,280£11,328£10,700Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£11,293£11,341£10,712
Pension Creditper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£974£978£923Birmingham Erdington is higher£914£918£867
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£950£954£901Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£951£955£902
Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25
£53£53£50Birmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count£51£51£49
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£719£722£682Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£720£723£683
Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£176£177£167Birmingham Erdington is higher£152£153£144
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£196£197£186Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher£211£212£200
Universal Creditper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£2,891£2,904£2,743Birmingham Erdington is higher£2,688£2,699£2,550
Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25
£701£704£665Birmingham Erdington is higher£315£316£299
Employment and Support Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£474£476£449Birmingham Erdington is higher£459£461£436
Jobseeker's Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£13£13£12Birmingham Erdington is higher£7.64£7.68£7.25
Income Supportper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25
£13£13£12Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher£18£18£17
Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£7.25£7.28£6.88Birmingham Erdington is higher£5.17£5.19£4.90
State Pensionper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026
1,002.0Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher1,015.5
Pension Creditper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026
204.2Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher209.8
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026
194.8Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher197.8
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026
100.6Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher106.6
Universal Creditper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, May 2026
354.6Birmingham Erdington is higher315.2
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, March 2026
44.4Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count45.5
Show the numbers
| Measure | Birmingham Erdington | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East | Higher |
|---|---|---|---|
| All benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £5,611£5,635£5,322 | £5,148£5,170£4,883 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Pensioner benefitsper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £13,257£13,313£12,574 | £13,209£13,266£12,530 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Working-age benefitsper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £3,587£3,602£3,402 | £3,385£3,399£3,210 | Birmingham Erdington |
| State Pensionper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £11,280£11,328£10,700 | £11,293£11,341£10,712 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Pension Creditper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £974£978£923 | £914£918£867 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £950£954£901 | £951£955£902 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper person aged 66 and over, 2024-25 | £53£53£50 | £51£51£49 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £719£722£682 | £720£723£683 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £176£177£167 | £152£153£144 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £196£197£186 | £211£212£200 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Universal Creditper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £2,891£2,904£2,743 | £2,688£2,699£2,550 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25 | £701£704£665 | £315£316£299 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Employment and Support Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £474£476£449 | £459£461£436 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Jobseeker's Allowanceper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £13£13£12 | £7.64£7.68£7.25 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Income Supportper person aged 16 to 64, 2024-25 | £13£13£12 | £18£18£17 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £7.25£7.28£6.88 | £5.17£5.19£4.90 | Birmingham Erdington |
| State Pensionper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026 | 1,002.0 | 1,015.5 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Pension Creditper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026 | 204.2 | 209.8 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 people aged 66 and over, March 2026 | 194.8 | 197.8 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026 | 100.6 | 106.6 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Universal Creditper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, May 2026 | 354.6 | 315.2 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 people aged 16 to 64, March 2026 | 44.4 | 45.5 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
Per resident
Birmingham Erdington is higher on 10 of 22 measures, and Middlesbrough and Thornaby East on 12. Each row has its own scale from zero. Money is in 2026-27 prices2026-27 prices, using CPI inflationcash terms, not adjusted for inflation.1-11
Birmingham Erdington Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
All benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£5,611£5,635£5,322Birmingham Erdington is higher£5,148£5,170£4,883
Pensioner benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£1,717£1,724£1,628Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£1,772£1,779£1,681
Working-age benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£2,291£2,300£2,173Birmingham Erdington is higher£2,184£2,193£2,072
State Pensionper resident, 2024-25
£1,461£1,467£1,386Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£1,515£1,521£1,437
Pension Creditper resident, 2024-25
£126£127£120Birmingham Erdington is higher£123£123£116
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£123£124£117Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£128£128£121
Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£6.82£6.85£6.47Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£6.87£6.90£6.52
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£719£722£682Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count£720£723£683
Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£176£177£167Birmingham Erdington is higher£152£153£144
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper resident, 2024-25
£125£126£119Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher£136£137£129
Universal Creditper resident, 2024-25
£1,846£1,854£1,751Birmingham Erdington is higher£1,735£1,742£1,645
Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25
£701£704£665Birmingham Erdington is higher£315£316£299
Employment and Support Allowanceper resident, 2024-25
£302£304£287Birmingham Erdington is higher£297£298£281
Jobseeker's Allowanceper resident, 2024-25
£8.34£8.37£7.91Birmingham Erdington is higher£4.93£4.95£4.68
Income Supportper resident, 2024-25
£8.40£8.44£7.97Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher£12£12£11
Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25
£7.25£7.28£6.88Birmingham Erdington is higher£5.17£5.19£4.90
State Pensionper 1,000 residents, March 2026
129.8Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher136.2
Pension Creditper 1,000 residents, March 2026
26.4Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher28.1
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026
25.2Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher26.5
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026
100.6Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher106.6
Universal Creditper 1,000 residents, May 2026
226.4Birmingham Erdington is higher203.4
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026
28.4Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higherDepends on how you count29.3
Show the numbers
| Measure | Birmingham Erdington | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East | Higher |
|---|---|---|---|
| All benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £5,611£5,635£5,322 | £5,148£5,170£4,883 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Pensioner benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £1,717£1,724£1,628 | £1,772£1,779£1,681 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Working-age benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £2,291£2,300£2,173 | £2,184£2,193£2,072 | Birmingham Erdington |
| State Pensionper resident, 2024-25 | £1,461£1,467£1,386 | £1,515£1,521£1,437 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Pension Creditper resident, 2024-25 | £126£127£120 | £123£123£116 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £123£124£117 | £128£128£121 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £6.82£6.85£6.47 | £6.87£6.90£6.52 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £719£722£682 | £720£723£683 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £176£177£167 | £152£153£144 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper resident, 2024-25 | £125£126£119 | £136£137£129 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Universal Creditper resident, 2024-25 | £1,846£1,854£1,751 | £1,735£1,742£1,645 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Housing Benefitper resident, 2024-25 | £701£704£665 | £315£316£299 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Employment and Support Allowanceper resident, 2024-25 | £302£304£287 | £297£298£281 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Jobseeker's Allowanceper resident, 2024-25 | £8.34£8.37£7.91 | £4.93£4.95£4.68 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Income Supportper resident, 2024-25 | £8.40£8.44£7.97 | £12£12£11 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Other benefitsper resident, 2024-25 | £7.25£7.28£6.88 | £5.17£5.19£4.90 | Birmingham Erdington |
| State Pensionper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 129.8 | 136.2 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Pension Creditper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 26.4 | 28.1 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 25.2 | 26.5 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymentper 1,000 residents, July 2026 | 100.6 | 106.6 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Universal Creditper 1,000 residents, May 2026 | 226.4 | 203.4 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymentper 1,000 residents, March 2026 | 28.4 | 29.3 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
Total
Birmingham Erdington is higher on 16 of 22 measures, and Middlesbrough and Thornaby East on 6. Each row has its own scale from zero. Money is in 2026-27 prices2026-27 prices, using CPI inflationcash terms, not adjusted for inflation.1-11
Birmingham Erdington Middlesbrough and Thornaby East
All benefitstotal, 2024-25
£707.9m£710.9m£671.5mBirmingham Erdington is higher£624.0m£626.6m£591.9m
Pensioner benefitstotal, 2024-25
£216.6m£217.5m£205.4mBirmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count£214.8m£215.7m£203.7m
Working-age benefitstotal, 2024-25
£289.0m£290.2m£274.1mBirmingham Erdington is higher£264.8m£265.9m£251.1m
State Pensiontotal, 2024-25
£184.3m£185.1m£174.8mBirmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count£183.6m£184.4m£174.2m
Pension Credittotal, 2024-25
£15.9m£16.0m£15.1mBirmingham Erdington is higher£14.9m£14.9m£14.1m
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£15.5m£15.6m£14.7mBirmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count£15.5m£15.5m£14.7m
Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£0.86m£0.86m£0.82mBirmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count£0.83m£0.84m£0.79m
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£90.7m£91.1m£86.0mBirmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count£87.2m£87.6m£82.7m
Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£22.2m£22.3m£21.1mBirmingham Erdington is higher£18.5m£18.5m£17.5m
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, 2024-25
£15.8m£15.9m£15.0mMiddlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher£16.5m£16.6m£15.7m
Universal Credittotal, 2024-25
£233.0m£233.9m£221.0mBirmingham Erdington is higher£210.3m£211.2m£199.4m
Housing Benefittotal, 2024-25
£88.5m£88.9m£83.9mBirmingham Erdington is higher£38.2m£38.3m£36.2m
Employment and Support Allowancetotal, 2024-25
£38.2m£38.3m£36.2mBirmingham Erdington is higher£35.9m£36.1m£34.1m
Jobseeker's Allowancetotal, 2024-25
£1.1m£1.1m£1.00mBirmingham Erdington is higher£0.60m£0.60m£0.57m
Income Supporttotal, 2024-25
£1.1m£1.1m£1.0mMiddlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher£1.4m£1.4m£1.3m
Other benefitstotal, 2024-25
£0.92m£0.92m£0.87mBirmingham Erdington is higher£0.63m£0.63m£0.59m
State Pensiontotal, March 2026
16,370Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher16,510
Pension Credittotal, March 2026
3,336Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher3,411
Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, March 2026
3,183Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher3,216
Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, July 2026
12,696Middlesbrough and Thornaby East is higher12,918
Universal Credittotal, May 2026
28,569Birmingham Erdington is higher24,657
Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, March 2026
3,578Birmingham Erdington is higherDepends on how you count3,556
Show the numbers
| Measure | Birmingham Erdington | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East | Higher |
|---|---|---|---|
| All benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £707.9m£710.9m£671.5m | £624.0m£626.6m£591.9m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Pensioner benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £216.6m£217.5m£205.4m | £214.8m£215.7m£203.7m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Working-age benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £289.0m£290.2m£274.1m | £264.8m£265.9m£251.1m | Birmingham Erdington |
| State Pensiontotal, 2024-25 | £184.3m£185.1m£174.8m | £183.6m£184.4m£174.2m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Pension Credittotal, 2024-25 | £15.9m£16.0m£15.1m | £14.9m£14.9m£14.1m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £15.5m£15.6m£14.7m | £15.5m£15.5m£14.7m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Winter Fuel Payment and Pension Age Winter Heating Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £0.86m£0.86m£0.82m | £0.83m£0.84m£0.79m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £90.7m£91.1m£86.0m | £87.2m£87.6m£82.7m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Disability Living Allowance and Child Disability Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £22.2m£22.3m£21.1m | £18.5m£18.5m£17.5m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, 2024-25 | £15.8m£15.9m£15.0m | £16.5m£16.6m£15.7m | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Universal Credittotal, 2024-25 | £233.0m£233.9m£221.0m | £210.3m£211.2m£199.4m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Housing Benefittotal, 2024-25 | £88.5m£88.9m£83.9m | £38.2m£38.3m£36.2m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Employment and Support Allowancetotal, 2024-25 | £38.2m£38.3m£36.2m | £35.9m£36.1m£34.1m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Jobseeker's Allowancetotal, 2024-25 | £1.1m£1.1m£1.00m | £0.60m£0.60m£0.57m | Birmingham Erdington |
| Income Supporttotal, 2024-25 | £1.1m£1.1m£1.0m | £1.4m£1.4m£1.3m | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Other benefitstotal, 2024-25 | £0.92m£0.92m£0.87m | £0.63m£0.63m£0.59m | Birmingham Erdington |
| State Pensiontotal, March 2026 | 16,370 | 16,510 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Pension Credittotal, March 2026 | 3,336 | 3,411 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Attendance Allowance and Pension Age Disability Paymenttotal, March 2026 | 3,183 | 3,216 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Personal Independence Payment and Adult Disability Paymenttotal, July 2026 | 12,696 | 12,918 | Middlesbrough and Thornaby East |
| Universal Credittotal, May 2026 | 28,569 | 24,657 | Birmingham Erdington |
| Carer's Allowance and Carer Support Paymenttotal, March 2026 | 3,578 | 3,556 | Birmingham Erdington |
Sources
Each area's page lists the limits of its figures and where each one comes from.
- 1Department for Work and Pensions. Benefit expenditure by local authority, 2024-25. Published 15 December 2025. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 2Department for Work and Pensions. Benefit expenditure by parliamentary constituency, 2024-25. Published 15 December 2025. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 3Department for Work and Pensions. Stat-Xplore benefit caseloads and awards. Published 6 October 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 4Social Security Scotland. Adult Disability Payment statistics to 31 July 2026. Published 14 September 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 5Social Security Scotland. Child Disability Payment statistics to 30 June 2026. Published 17 August 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 6Social Security Scotland. Pension Age Disability Payment statistics to 31 July 2026. Published 14 September 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 7Social Security Scotland. Carer Support Payment statistics to 30 June 2026. Published 10 August 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 8Social Security Scotland. Winter heating benefits statistics for winter 2025/26. Published 18 May 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 9Office for National Statistics. Population estimates by local authority (Nomis NM_2002_1). Published 5 October 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 10Office for National Statistics. Population estimates by 2024 parliamentary constituency (Nomis NM_2014_1). Published 5 October 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.
- 11National Records of Scotland. Population estimates for other geographies, mid-2011 to mid-2024. Published 31 August 2026. Open Government Licence v3.0. Data release 2026-10-08.2.